Housemade NOT Homemade Please
Housemade on the other hand is much better - because it tells me that whatever this particular item is - it isn't bought from a distributor. Rather, they're putting it together back in the kitchen.
I know it is an odd request.
Please restaurant operators: Stop with this homemade madness. I don't want homemade.
(Oh, and while you're at it, please stop calling anything the "First Annual", too.)