Female Bob Dylan Impersonators

Posted by on
(First...a word:  sorry about all the videos lately.  Too many are catching my eye!)  A month or two ago, Nat and I took the babe to see "When in Rome" at the Loma Theatre up in Michigan.  Yes...it was terrible, but it was the only thing that was showing at the time we wanted to go (trying to fit a feature film in between feedings/naps is challenging!).

The high point of the film was a song performed by Adele - "Make You Feel My Love" - a song written by Bob Dylan and included on the Time Out of Mind Album.  I've always liked the song - especially the contrast between the context of the song and Dylan's rough voice work.  It always stood out on a VERY strong album.

Hearing it in the movie got me thinking -  might Bob Dylan end up being a great - maybe the greatest - songwriter for female artists?  His works have such tender moments - but with him singing them - they end up elsewhere.  I've included the Adele version of "Make you Feel My Love" below.  But I've also included a few other covers by females as well.  I might argue that each of them are **better** than his original.  Blasphemy?  Tell me what you think.


Comments

  1. AnonymousMarch 6, 2010 at 3:17 PM

    very nice, all of them..as for better than dylan himself well...it's like comparing apples to oranges, dylan is the more unique. these women do a good job though. heard a woman singer do "Tomorrow is a long time" and hated the song then because it was too sweet.

    ReplyDelete
  2. AnonymousMarch 10, 2010 at 1:08 PM

    I wholeheartedly disagree. First these are not even the best covers of these songs. Adele is flat, using only her register, Baez style, no creativity, Neko is null compared to the very funky Bette Middler version, and Sophie Z thinks she is Charlotte Gainsbourg and like Charlotte did for Just Like a woman destroys Most of the time (The Dylan version is outstanding). As far as Mississipi, the 3 chicks do a far better job than Sheryl, but Bob alone can communicate the spirit of the song. For the chicks it is just music, with HIM, the lyrics speak.

    There are good Dylan cover by women, starting with several nice BOTT pieces by miss Corvette, and the 30th anniversary "Released", or Shawn Colvin's "Lonesome" ... These are the good covers - they hang on the depth of the lyrics and don't just add strings and a high pitched tremolo. They speak.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jake ParrilloMarch 10, 2010 at 1:10 PM

    Nice feedback! Appreciate you sharing your thoughts. I'm - by no means - a Bob Dylan expert. In fact...you probably will frown on me because I like 3 "late" records best - better than earlier music. Modern Times, L&T, and TOOM are my top 3.

    But...I was born in 1978!

    ReplyDelete
  4. AnonymousMarch 10, 2010 at 1:47 PM

    Cat Power's "I believe in you" fabulous on every level!

    ReplyDelete
  5. UnknownMarch 10, 2010 at 4:22 PM

    Don't miss these Dylan Covers by Patches & Gretchen - http://clck.it/94qJyb

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Be nice to each other here.

Popular posts from this blog

Lou Malnati's Salad Dressing Recipe as Published in the 60's

Posted by on
Image
Earlier this winter, I wrote about the old Lou Malnati's menu and mentioned that as I was waiting around for my pie to finish up, I spied an old Chicago Tribune article posted on the wall that included the original Lou Malnati's Italian Salad Dressing Recipe.  The Tribune reporter called it "prized".  We were set to host a little pizza party over the weekend, so I figured I'd give it a shot.  Here's the article as seen through my mobile phone's camera. I'm not a wine drinker, so the fact that the recipe called for Burgundy wine didn't strike me as odd.  I went shopping at Angelo Caputos in Addison - a really incredible shopping experience - and when I got to the wine section I found Burgundy wine was carried ONLY in those HUGE jugs.  And they were dirt cheap.  The only issue is that needed just 4 ounces.  We ended up with a whole-lotta-wine that Nat won't drink. I've taken the recipe and modified it a bit by eliminating the percentage...
Read more

Tom Thayer's Italian Beef Recipe

Posted by on
Image
TOM’S TAILGATER ITALIAN BEEF COURTESY OF Steve Dahl  and  DAHL.COM Ingredients: One 3 ½ to 4 pound boneless beef chuck pot roast One package of Zesty Italian Salad Dressing and Recipe Mix One 16 oz. jar of hot giardiniera One 16 oz. jar of mild giardiniera One dozen baguettes (French rolls) Directions: In a four-quart Crock-Pot, pour in one bottle of giardiniera. Place the roast on top of the layer of giardiniera. Sprinkle the salad dressing mixture on top of the roast. Add the second bottle of giardiniera to the top of the roast. Cover Crock-Pot and cook on high for 6 to 8 hours. When fork tender, shred the roast in the Crock-Pot and allow it to combine with the other ingredients. Slice the baguettes in half and pile on the beef and giardiniera mixture. ------------------------------------ For the babe's baptism party, we hosted a collection of family and friends back at our house after the church proceedings. We ordered some of t...
Read more

Overwintering Disneyland Roses With Leaf Mulch - Floribunda Roses - December 2024

Posted by on
Image
Yesterday, I posted photos of how I'm attempting to overwinter some Dahlia tubers in the ground and in a couple of those pics, you might have peeked at the chicken wire cages next to the piles of mulch on the dahlia tubers.  Those chicken wire cages are full of fallen leaves and are set on top of the three Disneyland Rose crowns along the southside of our house. See below for a couple of photos showing how I set up the ring of chicken wire and filled it with mulched-up leaves: These roses struggled this year, so here's hoping this little bit of extra Winter protection is going to help them get through the cold.
Read more